Da: "coalit"
Oggetto: [listacoalit] LIONEL TATE (FLORIDA) aged 14.
Data: giovedì 7 giugno 2001 3.25
> URGENT ACTION: LEGAL CONCERN LIONEL TATE (FLORIDA) aged 14.
>
> From: Amnesty International AUSTRALIA:
>
> Lionel Tate recently began a sentence of life imprisonment without the
> possibility of parole, for a crime committed in 1999 when he was 12 years
old.
>
> His sentence violates international law.
>
> His lawyers have filed a clemency petition to the Governor of Florida, and
Amnesty International is calling for Lionel Tate's sentence to be commuted
and his treatment brought into line with international standards.
>
> On 25 January, Lionel Tate was convicted as an adult of the first-degree
murder of his playmate, six-year-old Tiffany Eunick, who was killed on 28
July 1999. The jury rejected the defence claim that the 12-year-old boy had
accidentally killed the much smaller girl while mimicking professional
wrestling moves that he had seen on television. Prior to the trial, the
defence rejected the prosecution's offer of a sentence of three years in
juvenile detention, followed by a year of house arrest and 10 years of
probation, in return for a plea of guilty to second-degree murder.
>
> At his sentencing on 10 March, Lionel Tate received the mandatory prison
sentence under Florida law of life without parole. If the sentence is not
reduced on appeal or by executive clemency, he will die in prison.
>
> Lionel Tate's sentence violates the principle that the state's treatment
of children who commit crimes, however serious, must focus on the
possibility of the child's rehabilitation and successful reintegration into
society.
>
> Indeed, under international standards, maximizing this possibility should
be one of the primary guiding principles motivating the state's response.
>
> Article 37(a) of the Convention on the Rights of the Child (CRC) states:
> "Neither capital punishment nor life imprisonment without possibility of
release shall be imposed for offences committed by persons below eighteen
years of age".
>
> While the USA is one of only two countries (the other being Somalia),
which have not ratified this treaty (191 countries have), it has
> signed it. As such, it has bound itself under international law not to do
anything which would defeat the object and purpose of the treaty, pending
the decision on whether to ratify it.
>
> Article 37(b) of the CRC calls upon states to use imprisonment against a
child "only as a measure of last resort and for the shortest appropriate
period of time".
>
> Article 40 calls upon states to treat children found to have violated the
law in a way that "takes into account the child's age and the desirability
of promoting the child's reintegration and the child's assuming a
constructive role in society".
>
> Article 14(4) of the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights,
which the USA ratified in 1992, states: "In the case of juvenile persons,
the procedure shall be such as will take account of their age and the
desirability of promoting their rehabilitation".
>
> The UN Rules for the Protection of Juveniles deprived of their Liberty
furthermore state that any such deprivation should only be under conditions
> that guarantee "meaningful activities and programmes which would serve to
promote and sustain [the juveniles'] health and self-respect, to foster
their sense of responsibility and encourage those attitudes and skills that
will
> assist them in developing their potential as members of society".
>
> In Florida, the Governor has the unfettered discretion to grant clemency
with the approval of at least three members of the Cabinet. The Governor
could call a special clemency meeting on the case at any time. Lionel Tate's
clemency petition, including a letter from Amnesty International, reached
Governor Bush on 1 June. In such cases, the organization does not specify in
detail what sentence is appropriate, only that it should conform to
international standards.
>
> Background Information:-
>
> During the past two decades in the USA, in response to public concern
about crimes committed by young people, federal and state governments have
significantly expanded the role of the general criminal justice system with
respect to children and increased the severity of sanctions that courts may
impose on children. The growing tendency in the USA to prosecute and punish
children as if they were adults, rather than in the separate juvenile
justice system, is inconsistent with the approach encouraged by
international standards, that governments should establish laws, procedures,
authorities and institutions specifically for children.
>
> There are many people in the USA serving life imprisonment without the
> possibility of parole for crimes committed when they were under 18.
>
> Amnesty International knows of none from this group who was as young as
Lionel Tate at the time of the offence. His case is therefore starkly
illustrative of a wider problem, and the organization is taking this action
as part of its efforts to persuade US authorities to bring their country
into line with international standards on the treatment of child offenders.
His sentence should be commuted as a matter of urgency and the state's
efforts turned towards maximizing his chance for successful reintegration
into society at the earliest possible time, rather than throwing away the
key.
>
> RECOMMENDED ACTION:
>
> Please send letters, faxes, or emails in English or your own language, in
your own words:
> - expressing sympathy for Tiffany Eunick's family, explaining that you are
not seeking to belittle her tragic death or the suffering it has caused;
> - expressing concern, however, that Lionel Tate, who was 12 years old at
the time, has been given a sentence of life imprisonment without the
possibility of parole, which violates international law;
> - noting that the sentence has received widespread international
attention, being out of step with commonly held views of juvenile justice,
and that such cases are damaging Florida's, and the USA's, reputation in the
world;
> - calling for the sentence to be commuted and that the state's response be
aimed at maximizing Lionel Tate's potential for successful reintegration
into society, in line with international standards recognized around the
world.